I am modelling sand slopes in Plaxis 3D using an HP model. I am using soil parameters from “Modelling of Soil Behaviour with Hypoplasticity” by David Masin (2019). During the models the phreatic surface is rising. The problem I am having with my models are that the total displacement I get with the model is extremely small. A very loose slope with a height of 20 m only settles about 10 mm during gravity loading. I want to know if anyone has had similar problems and whether they know how to fix it?
Small displacements when using HP model in Plaxis 3D
Related Articles

liquefaction simulation with abaqus
Ruibin HouFinite Elements7 Views 3,710
Hello, everyone I am an abaqus user and developer. Recently, I want to simulating the liquefaction phenomenon with abaqus/standard or abaqus/explicit. As I know, this cannot be realized using the […] 
UMAT for hypoplastic subroutine
Naif AlsanabaniFinite Elements4 Views 3,510
Hello all, Could you please anyone provide me umat for Hypoplastic model that used as subroutine in Abqus 6.14. With Best Regards Naif Mohammed 
Problem in calculating Lateral displacement of the pile using Hypoplastic clay model
arsalan AhmadFinite Elements4 Views 2,806
Hy Professor David, I am trying to verify the result of one of your paper by the title ‘Cyclic lateral response and failure mechanisms of semirigid pile in soft clay: […] 
Hypoplasticity sand convergence issues
anis kheffacheFinite Elements0 Views 2,908
Hi everyone, i am modeling laterally loaded monopile using abaqus, My 3d model looks like this, only half of the model is simulated, symmetry boundary conditions is applied to the […] 
ABAQUS modeling: Warning about unconnected regions when using hypoplasticity subroutine
Jasmine LokeshFinite Elements0 Views 4,016
I ran a simple 3D model with symmetry boundary conditions first using elastic material and then as hypoplastic using a subroutine. However, in the former case, I don’t get the […] 
set cavitation limit in ABAQUS/STANDARD when using SANISAND umat
Zhentao LiuFinite Elements6 Views 2,448
Dear all I am recently working on the mechanical characteristics of large diameter monopiles under horizontal loads.The numerical simulation part of this project was carried out in ABAQUS/STANDARD and for […] 
Hypoplastic model for clays in a Plaxis 2D simulation – Problem
Daniel ValenciaFinite Elements2 Views 2,802
Hello everybody, Using Hypoplastic model for clays, with intergranular concept parameters, I am simulating a simple oedometer test, phase by phase, using a dummy layer on the top of the […] 
Modeling of granular soil by using UMAT hypoplastic in Abaqus
Naif AlsanabaniFinite Elements5 Views 3,501
Dear all I am using the UMAT of hypoplastic model for simulation soil (3D modeling) under cyclic loading. The analysis was completed at geostatic step. But for consolidation step (soil, […]
Who is Online
No one is online right now
Search SoilModels Website
Recent posts
 Presentations from Prague Geotechnical Days 2023 including 29th Prague Geotechical Lecture by Yannis Dafalias 25.5.2023
 Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus. 17.5.2023
 An error in the SANISAND umat runtime 8.5.2023
 Htypoplastic Model in Miidas GTS NX 25.4.2023
 set cavitation limit in ABAQUS/STANDARD when using SANISAND umat 2.4.2023
 FE formulation and software 25.3.2023
 Multiobjective analysis of the Sand Hypoplasticity model calibration 24.3.2023
 Problem with SANISAND UMAT 7.3.2023
 Prague Geotechnical Days 2023 (22nd – 23rd of May) with Prague Geotechnical Lecture by prof. Yannis Dafalias 28.2.2023
 What is an appropriate damping model for dynamic liquefaction analysis of tailings storage facility in FLAC? 10.2.2023
 Abaqus vs Plaxis – Local Convergence Tolerances 2.2.2023
 Zbraslav sand – Cyclic tests by Charles University 17.1.2023
Recent Comments
 Francisco Mendez on Presentations from Prague Geotechnical Days 2023 including 29th Prague Geotechical Lecture by Yannis Dafalias
 Héctor Montenegro on Extended Mohr–Coulomb (EMC)
 Kassem Dib on Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus.
 Isma Khabis on Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus.
 Isma Khabis on Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus.
 Kassem Dib on Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus.
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Arie Koot on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Arie Koot on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Arie Koot on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Arie Koot on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
 Zhentao Liu on An error in the SANISAND umat runtime
Hi Arno, it is really hard to grasp what you are doing from this information. There are various parameter sets in the book you cite, at least two hypoplastic models (clay, sand), with and without intergranular strain concept…?? You speak about water rising, but then that the problem is in gravity loading stages. So water probably does not play any role there? It is impossible to reply to question which is formulated this way…
I apologise, I should clarify the problem. The ultimate goal of my model is to back analyse centrifuge models conducted at the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology. The slope is a homogenous slope and I am using the Toyoura sand parameters from “Modelling of Soil Behaviour with Hypoplasticity”. In the tests the groundwater started rising. That part of the model works fine. However, the issue I am having is that from the beginning of the model (from the initial phase which is gravity loading) the displacements in the model is extremely small. I am getting only a few mm displacement in a slope that is 20 m high, irrespective of which phase I am calculating. I have tried changing boundary conditions and even using different soil parameters (i.e. Hochstetten and Karlsruhe sand). I have checked all the parameters and units multiple times and the model conditions as well. No matter what parameters or conditions I use, I keep getting extremely small displacements during all phases of my calculations. When I use other types of models such as the MohrCoulomb model, I do not have any of the issues with the small displacements.
Hi Arno,
First of all, please use parameters validated using HongKong centrifuge simulations, for example from
Ng, C. W. W., Boonyarak, T. and Mašín, D. (2013). Threedimensional centrifuge and numerical modeling of the interaction between perpendicularly crossing tunnels. Canadian Geotechnical Journal 50, No. 9, 935946.
This is more specific than generic parameters from the book (calibrated long ago in Karlsruhe).
Then, please try to calculate with and without intergranular strain concept, to see if there is any difference (this will let us understand where the problem was initiated).
David
Hi David
I checked with the parameters from that journal paper. Without the intergranular strain concept I get a bit better displacements during gravity loading (about 0.4 m for a slope with a 20 m height). However, for the rest of the phases the displacements are still small.
When I activate the intergranular strain concept I get strange errors in the model during the initial phase. I get errors with both the displacement and stresses in general. Please find a link to some screenshots I took of the errors I get.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1tZbnmXYu9LYZlqubX1O6BoxbBe5_8al
Arno