Hello, everyone. I have encountered an issue during the simulation of triaxial compression of rocks using the perfectly elasto-plastic Mohr-Coulomb model in Abaqus. In my simulation, the stress-strain curve consists of two inclined straight lines (Fig. 1). But in theoretical, the stress-strain curve should be composed of an inclined straight line followed by a horizontal line. Could anyone explain why this inconsistency occurs?
Here are the details of my setup: the height of the cylinder is 100mm and the radius is 50mm (Fig. 2), the cohesion and friction angle are 21.569MPa and 35.42°, both transformed from the rock parameters, and the flow rule is associated. In addition, I would like to know how to obtain the yield curve based on the results of the triaxial compression test?
Triaxial compression test using Mohr-Coulomb model in Abaqus
Related Articles
-
ERROR Message when using UMAT_hcea with ABAQUS
Lukas Reindl||Constitutive Modelling|3 |Views 7,334
Hi all! I am modelling some triaxial compressions in ABAQUS with Weald Clay. The constitutive law i am using is the clay hypoplasticity by Mašín. When running the program using […] -
Problem with VUMAT interface
Giada Orlando||Constitutive Modelling|4 |Views 5,475
Dear All, I am trying to run the VUMAT interface by Prof. Binen with the Sand Hypoplasticity. However, when I run the simulation Abaqus returns the following error: “Problem during […] -
multi yield surface model
kamal paknejad||Constitutive Modelling|6 |Views 5,569
Hi everyone, i am trying to write umat subroutine for multi yield surface plasticity model.if its possible give me some information to do my project better and if some body […] -
ALERT Geomaterials – SoilModels support declaration
David Mašín||Constitutive Modelling|0 |Views 5,019
ALERT Geomaterials (The Alliance of Laboratories in Europe for Education, Research and Technology) is a European organisation including 33 Universities or Organisations, which are most active in the field of numerical […] -
Errors of sand hypoplastic model with Abaqus Vumat
Kunpeng Wang||Constitutive Modelling|12 |Views 16,466
Dear all, Recently, I have been working on the simulation of a pile-soil interaction with CEL method in Abaqus/Explicit. I simulate the sand with the Sand Hypoplasticity Model provided by […] -
Suggestions for an Advanced Constitutive Model in FEM-Based Dynamic Slope Stability Analysis
zahras zahrasss||Constitutive Modelling|0 |Views 2,339
Dear colleagues, I am planning to conduct a dynamic stability analysis of a slope using the finite element method (FEM). I intend to implement the analysis through coding and utilize […] -
CONSTUTUTIVE MODELLING
MOHD SAQIB||Constitutive Modelling|0 |Views 6,297
Can SANISAND version given in soil model work well for cyclic simple shear test ? -
Interpreting results of sand hypoplastic model with Abaqus VUMAT
arsalan Ahmad||Constitutive Modelling|2 |Views 6,324
Dear concern, Recently i have modelled the soil pile interaction using Abaqus CEL method. The hypoplastic behavior of the soil is model using user subroutine VUMAT. The properties of the […]
Who is Online
No one is online right now
Search SoilModels Website
Recent posts
-
Problem in “Hoek Brown Softening” Model 30.4.2026
-
XFEM Hydraulic Fracturing in Abaqus – Pore Pressure Not Updating & Extremely Small Time Steps 28.4.2026
-
Correct my Plaxis FEM simulation in foundation bearing capacity results 3.4.2026
-
mohr coulomb 2D yield surface vs 3D mohr coulomb yield surface 28.2.2026
-
Problem with GeoStudio (Seepage) software 16.2.2026
-
Prague Geotechnical Days 2026 3.2.2026
-
Postdoctoral position at COFS, UWA 28.7.2025
-
Hypoplasticity clay in ABAQUS 23.7.2025
-
Drucker-Prager Cap 29.5.2025
-
Abaqus RITSS with hypoplastic 9.4.2025
-
Fellin UMAT subroutine 2.4.2025
-
Hypoplasticity clay for triaxial compression in abaqus 26.3.2025
Recent Comments
- Ding Yan on Download package of a complete dataset “Karlsruhe Kaolin – Cyclic tests (T. Wichtmann)”
- Arie Koot on mohr coulomb 2D yield surface vs 3D mohr coulomb yield surface
- Arie Koot on Multilaminate Model (Schädlich & Schweiger)
- Amir F on Problem with GeoStudio (Seepage) software
- Nabanita Saha on set cavitation limit in ABAQUS/STANDARD when using SANISAND umat
- Nabanita Saha on SANISAND Abaqus UMAT and Plaxis implementations
- Tian Fapai on SANISAND Abaqus UMAT and Plaxis implementations
- Heng Wang on Multilaminate Model (Schädlich & Schweiger)
- Zhang Hongwei on Download Package of Charles University Implementation of High Cycle Accumulation Model
- Ruimin Chen on Problem with VUMAT interface
- Nitesh Bhume on UMAT and oneAPI compiler issues. (SOLVED…i hope :p)
- Aleksandar Kostadinovic on Karlsruhe fine sand – Cyclic tests (T. Wichtmann)
- Amrane Moussa on Kadlíček, T., Ochmański, M., Mašín, D. and Duque, J. (2022) Report on Charles University implementation of high cycle accumulation model
- Ramon Varghese on SANISAND for FLAC3D Download
- Shuhan Cao on Hardening Soil or Hardening Soil-Small umat in Abaqus
- Kuikui Guigui on Hypoplastic Interface Model (Stutz et al., 2016)
- Kuikui Guigui on Download Package for Hypoplastic interface model and UMAT – FRIC interface
- Francisco José Mendez on Programme of the ALERT Olek Zienkiewicz school on Constitutive Modelling of Geomaterials, February 3 to 7, 2025, Prague, Czech Republic






Dear Hu Shihong,
It seems to me that there might be a confusion between the constitutive model and the model behavior. Each element within your model must behave according to the MC model you defined. However, the behavior of the model in total may not be elastic – perfectly plastic. To verify ths, you may load the model up to a higher strain value.
Can you share also the value of Poisson’s ratio?
Dear Mert Eyupgiller,
First much thank you for your reply. I think I have found the reason why the stress-strain curve appears to show hardening behavior when using an elastic-perfectly plastic constitutive model. The main reason is that before loading, the geostress is not balanced.
Additionally, the value of Poisson’s ratio is 0.25.
Dear Hu Shihong
I can add the following: The built in Abaqus Mohr-Coulomb model can never use associated plasticity, as the yield surface is different from the plastic potential.
I have the “classic” Mohr-Coulomb as an Abaqus UMAT. Feel free to reach out to me, if you are interested.
Best regards
Johan