Hello, everyone. I have encountered an issue during the simulation of triaxial compression of rocks using the perfectly elasto-plastic Mohr-Coulomb model in Abaqus. In my simulation, the stress-strain curve consists of two inclined straight lines (Fig. 1). But in theoretical, the stress-strain curve should be composed of an inclined straight line followed by a horizontal line. Could anyone explain why this inconsistency occurs?
Here are the details of my setup: the height of the cylinder is 100mm and the radius is 50mm (Fig. 2), the cohesion and friction angle are 21.569MPa and 35.42°, both transformed from the rock parameters, and the flow rule is associated. In addition, I would like to know how to obtain the yield curve based on the results of the triaxial compression test?
Triaxial compression test using Mohr-Coulomb model in Abaqus
Related Articles
-
CONSTUTUTIVE MODELLING
MOHD SAQIB||Constitutive Modelling|0 |
Views 4,786
Can SANISAND version given in soil model work well for cyclic simple shear test ? -
UDSM PLAXIS
nasim aftahi||Constitutive Modelling|2 |
Views 5,124
I implemented a unified dynamic soil model, but PLAXIS doesn’t calculate any strains, and it prints zero (or some times NaN amounts) into a text file. I’d like to know […] -
Non convergence problem in abaqus using hpoeca Clay Hypoplasticity in slope model
Yang Xue||Constitutive Modelling|4 |
Views 4,308
hello everyone! based on the strength reduction method in clay hypoplasticity, firstly, I used two steps belong to the static_general, the first step is impose a gravity load, and not […] -
SANISAND pile-soil-interaction ABAQUS
Lee Jae Sung||Constitutive Modelling|1 |
Views 4,964
Hi everyone: I am trying to use SANISAND as the constitutive model of soil, and use ABAQUS software to simulate pile-soil interaction. First step is “Geostatic”, the second step is […] -
Cyclic constitutive model for cemented granular soils
Hamoun Alimoradi||Constitutive Modelling|2 |
Views 4,365
if you could please let me know whether Is there any constitutive model exist for capturing cyclic response for cemented materials just like cemented sand and gravelly soils. -
Subroutine of SANISAND model
Pooja Patil||Constitutive Modelling|16 |
Views 5,566
I am trying use sanisand subroutine posted in this website. But it is not working. Getting no values for field variable in the odb. I think i am missing something. […] -
MSE walls design in Plaxis
Leo Alibert||Constitutive Modelling|2 |
Views 1,101
Hi everyone, this is my first post in this forum. I am collecting initial data on the most appropriate soil model for the analysis of a multitiered MSE wall. I […] -
Spurious oscillations in calculated accelerations
Piotr Kowalczyk||Constitutive Modelling|2 |
Views 4,433
Hello everyone, I have just a general question how people approach the problem of spurious oscillations generated in dynamic analysis when using nonlinear soil constitutive models. I understand sometimes numerical […]
Who is Online
No one is online right now
Search SoilModels Website
Recent posts
-
Hardening Soil or Hardening Soil-Small umat in Abaqus 2.1.2025
-
hypoplastic interface 11.12.2024
-
Triaxial Test Driver SANISAND 30.10.2024
-
REQUEST FOR EXPRESSIONS OF INTEREST (REOI) FOR PROJECT IN CONSTITUTIVE MODELLING 23.10.2024
-
Programme of the ALERT Olek Zienkiewicz school on Constitutive Modelling of Geomaterials, February 3 to 7, 2025, Prague, Czech Republic 11.10.2024
-
Connecting remote sensors to the Plaxis FEM 3D using python 26.7.2024
-
Intergranular Strain Extensions 16.7.2024
-
Abaqus Hypoplasticity Primary Variable Is Not Available 1.7.2024
-
Vumat to calculate excess pore in Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian ABAQUS 1.7.2024
-
Drucker Prager Cap Hardening Model 20.6.2024
-
Soil model for sand under drained cyclic loading 15.6.2024
-
In Abaqus how do we use *DLOAD for defining both user-defined pressure and body force simultaneously? 15.6.2024
Recent Comments
- Xiuzhe Wang on Hypoplasticity sand convergence issues
- Zheng Wanying on Example of FLAC3D data file
- Zheng Wanying on SANISAND for FLAC3D Download
- Anis Kheffache on Problem in using Hypoplastic model for sand in Abaqus.
- Micha Van der Sloot on PM4Sand for Plaxis Download
- Kiruthika Perumal on PM4Sand for Plaxis Download
- Shishir Kumar Sikder Amit on Mohr Coulomb umat in Abaqus
- Zhentao Liu on Hypoplasticity sand convergence issues
- Zhentao Liu on Combining Hypoplastic-sand and Hypoplastic-clay in one UMAT file
- Sumin Song on Clay and Sand hypoplasticity UMAT and Plaxis implementations, including UMAT-Plaxis interface
- KHA DIDJA on Issue in applying SANISAND04 UMAT to Boundary-Value-Problem
- Zhentao Liu on Problem in simulating CPT using SANISAND04
- Jin-Hu Li on Problem in simulating CPT using SANISAND04
- Johan Clausen on Triaxial compression test using Mohr-Coulomb model in Abaqus
- Ismail Khan on SANISAND for FLAC3D Download
- Tao Zhu on UMAT and oneAPI compiler issues. (SOLVED…i hope :p)
- Lei DAI on SANISAND for FLAC3D Download
- Yu Xiao on “Warning LNK4210” – hypoplastic clay UMAT
Dear Hu Shihong,
It seems to me that there might be a confusion between the constitutive model and the model behavior. Each element within your model must behave according to the MC model you defined. However, the behavior of the model in total may not be elastic – perfectly plastic. To verify ths, you may load the model up to a higher strain value.
Can you share also the value of Poisson’s ratio?
Dear Mert Eyupgiller,
First much thank you for your reply. I think I have found the reason why the stress-strain curve appears to show hardening behavior when using an elastic-perfectly plastic constitutive model. The main reason is that before loading, the geostress is not balanced.
Additionally, the value of Poisson’s ratio is 0.25.
Dear Hu Shihong
I can add the following: The built in Abaqus Mohr-Coulomb model can never use associated plasticity, as the yield surface is different from the plastic potential.
I have the “classic” Mohr-Coulomb as an Abaqus UMAT. Feel free to reach out to me, if you are interested.
Best regards
Johan